Chicago has been home to hundreds of synagogues over the years.
But for many, their role in the story of Jewish Chicago is in danger
of being lost. Robert Packer is trying to do something about that.
Three seemingly unrelated events
occurred in January 2003. Their
convergence changed Robert Packer's
life.
First, Packer and his wife, Fern,
decided to make a photographic record
of their families' history in Chicago.
Packer is an amateur photographer with
a darkroom and he thought that a
series of black-and-white photos
detailing his family's Chicago origins
in the stockyards district, and his
wife's family's beginnings on Maxwell
Street, would be just right for a wall
of their Buffalo Grove home.
When Packer went to photograph his in-
laws' synagogue, the former Beth
Itzchok of Albany Park, also known as
the Drake Avenue Shul, he found-
nothing. Many of the members had
joined its offshoot, Congregation Beth
Itzchok of West Rogers Park, but the
building was no longer there. The
synagogue, founded in the early 1920s,
had ceased to exist as a physical
presence. In its place was a park.
"There wasn't even a little plaque
there saying anything about this
beautiful synagogue that was there for
70 years," Packer says.
The second serendipitous event
occurred during the course of Packer's
job as a building inspector for
potential buyers of homes, condos and
industrial properties. Going into an
unfamiliar neighborhood to inspect a
building, he noticed an unusual church
with a condo building adjacent to it.
He asked around and discovered that
the church was once a synagogue, Beth
El Congregation, and the condo
building had once been its social
hall.
"I started wondering how many
synagogues were now churches,
community centers and condos," he
says. "I wondered how many were
falling apart due to lack of funds to
fix them or lack of community support.
I wondered how long it would be before
the record of the very existence of
Chicago Jewish communities would be
erased forever, like Maxwell Street."
With these questions in
mind, Packer discovered a newly
published book by two Chicago Jewish
historians. Called "A Walk to Shul:
Chicago Synagogues of Lawndale and
Stops on the Way," it was written by
Norman Schwartz and Bea Kraus and
published by the Chicago Historical
Society (see Chicago Jewish News, Oct.
31, 2003).
The slim volume included photographs
of many of the buildings that had once
housed synagogues-there were more than
70 of them during the area's height as
a Jewish population center-in addition
to Jewish schools, clubs and communal
buildings, along with histories of
each congregation and appealing
tidbits about life on the old West
Side.
Packer was delighted to see that there
was a picture of the Jewish People's
Institute, where he had gone to
nursery school in the early 1950s.
"I thought I had struck gold," he
says. Now that he knew the names and
locations of the old West Side
synagogues, he thought he could find a
book with their pictures and discover
a photo of the old Beth Itzchok to
complete his "family tree" of
synagogues.
Packer went to the logical place for
such a search, the Asher Library at
Spertus Institute of Jewish Studies.
There he met librarian Dan Sharon, who
would turn out to be instrumental to
Packer's project.
Sharon is well known to Jewish
historians and researchers for both
the depth and breadth of his knowledge
of Jewish life and history, including
Chicago Jewish history. If Sharon
doesn't know about a book or other
reference work, it probably doesn't
exist.
Packer found that out
when he asked Sharon for a book on
vanished Chicago synagogues. The
librarian found several. One, on old
Chicago churches and synagogues, had
250 beautiful color photos -- 235
churches and 25 synagogues, Packer
relates.
Another was a listing of addresses of
all of Chicago's synagogues, put
together nearly 20 years ago by
members of the Chicago Jewish
Historical Society. It was helpful,
but not what Packer was looking for.
"I said, Dan, I'm looking for a book
that has all the photos of Chicago
synagogues," Packer recalls. "He told
me that there wasn't one. He said, why
don't you take the photos? Donate them
here, and then we'll have a
chronicle."
Packer told Sharon that he wasn't much
of a photographer. "He said, Can you
take a picture?" Packer admitted that
he could, and Sharon encouraged him
to "do something no one else has ever
done."
"Dan is the greatest," Packer
says. "He is the whole reason this
happened."
"This" is Packer's decision to take up
Sharon's challenge to create a
photographic chronicle of Chicago's
forgotten synagogues.
First, though, he had to find out just
where all those synagogues were. He
enlisted the aid of three men he calls
his Brain Trust: Irving Cutler,
Chicago Jewish historian whose 1996
book "The Jews of Chicago: From Shtetl
to Suburb" was an invaluable resource;
Sid Sorkin, who wrote "12 Bridges to
an American City: Chicago's
Landsmanshaften," about the city's
Jewish fraternal societies; and
Schwartz, who helped Packer find the
addresses of more than 75 former
synagogues.
The three
men "were very enthusiastic about my
project," he says. "Little by little,
I was getting support from people I
never knew, who were very excited
about the whole idea of providing a
photographic history of what is slowly
disappearing."
He also spoke to family members of
Hyman Meites, who edited a monumental
1924 publication, "History of the Jews
of Chicago," and received permission
to use their archives.
Packer also spent much time at the
Chicago Public Library, where he
searched microfiche records from 1910
to 1950 to find the addresses of
synagogues.
"I had to create a whole archive from
scratch on my own in between working
full time," he says. "But it was a
labor of love."
Soon he began photographing the old
buildings. When he couldn't find one,
he tried to find out what had happened
to it.
"I photograph what's there," he
says. "It might be a shopping mall
parking lot. I try to find out what
happened. Some of the buildings were
torn down-what happened to the
members?"
While
he was photographing, Parker also
worked on creating a "flow chart" of
Chicago synagogues beginning in 1847
with the city's very first one,
Kehilath Anshe Maariv, and continuing
through the present day.
"That was more difficult than taking
the pictures, with all the merging and
the moving," he says. "Sometimes there
was a consolidation of several
synagogues into a single one. That's
an amazing story that no one has ever
done."
One idea kept pushing Packer forward:
that a record of Jewish life in
Chicago must be preserved.
He likes to cite figures showing that
in the 1930s, Chicago had 290,000 Jews
and 300 synagogues; in 2003, there
were 260,000 Jews but, with the
exception of West Rogers Park, only
seven or eight synagogues left in
Chicago proper.
The city's spotty record on historical
preservation also propelled him
on. "Within a generation, there won't
be any physical or cultural evidence
that the Jewish population lived in
Albany Park or Lawndale or South
Shore," he says. "Chicago is literally
tearing down a cultural, ethnic and
religious group that was very
important to the growth of the city.
Within a generation, there won't be
any evidence that we existed."
That's the case with the
Maxwell Street neighborhood, once a
center of Jewish life, Packer
says. "There's no evidence of what it
was, not even a plaque. It's happening
everywhere, in every former Jewish
community in Chicago. We contributed
culturally, religiously and
architecturally to the community, and
within a very short time the physical
evidence will no longer exist."
"Chicago only protects landmarks
selectively," he says. He is pleased
by commemorative plaques erected at
the former site of KAM, the city's
first congregation, and the Jewish
People's Institute on Douglas
Boulevard, but believes that other
buildings have been torn down with no
markers to indicate that they ever
existed.
"I understand that the city has to
change, but not even to leave some
kind of a plaque ..." he says.
He also found that many of the former
synagogues have been turned into
churches-and that many are in serious
need of repair. Often, the churches
don't have the money to renovate the
old buildings.
At the
former South Side Hebrew Congregation
at 74th and Chappel in the South Shore
area, now a Baptist church, Packer
talked to the pastor. "It was a
magnificent, beautiful synagogue and
now the ceiling is caving in," he
says. "The church can't afford to
replace the roof." Packer plans to use
his completed photographs to host a
fund-raiser to help the church put on
a new roof.
"Most of the pastors at the churches
I've visited are very skeptical," he
says. "They're wondering, why does
this Jewish guy want to take a picture
of my church? But I'm tenacious, and a
few have opened their doors to me."
Among the buildings he has
photographed are the former
Congregation B'nai Zion in East Rogers
Park, where his family belonged during
his childhood. Last year, the
synagogue closed its doors, merging
with another congregation.
More than 50 churches, Packer
estimates, still have the original
stained glass windows from when they
were synagogues. After he finishes his
current project, he plans to undertake
another detailing these windows.
In fact, Packer now plans to create a
three-volume project. The first book
will be the photographic record of old
synagogues, the second will deal with
Jewish communal buildings, and the
third with stained glass windows.
Taken together they will give "a
cultural, archaeological and physical
history of the Jews of Chicago," he
says.
Even
as he works on the project, Packer
sees the Jewish community changing. He
finds irony in the fact that two
Chicago synagogues with the same name
are both in danger of closing. Agudas
Achim North Shore Congregation in
Uptown has been struggling for years
and still needs much renovation. And
Beth Shalom B'nai Zaken-Agudath Achim
Congregation on South Houston Avenue
has recently puts its building up for
sale and is in the process of buying
another synagogue building in a
different neighborhood.
The changes now extend to the suburbs,
Packer says, noting that he recently
photographed Congregation Bnai Emunah
in Skokie, which is selling its
building and merging with Congregation
Beth Hillel in Wilmette.
Cutler, the Jewish historian, says
Packer's project is valuable. There
are only two books on Chicago's
historic synagogues, he says, the one
that covers Lawndale and another,
called "Faith and Form," that
discusses synagogue architecture.
"Outside of that, there's nothing," he
says, "so this is a very useful
project. There are a lot of old
synagogues scattered all around-the
North Side, South Side, suburbs-but
outside of Lawndale, there are photos
here and there but not a collection of
them."
Another of Packer's mentors, Norman
Schwartz, says that Packer's
photographic collection comes just at
the right time. "I started taking
pictures of synagogues in 1985 and
sometimes when I went back, a lot of
them were already torn down," he
says. "This is what's going on, and by
documenting them we preserve the
history. We don't have too many
histories of synagogues unless the
synagogue has moved to someplace else.
If these pictures had been taken
earlier, we might have documented some
cornerstones, at least."
He says
that a reader told him that his
photograph of a historic synagogue had
missed an architecturally significant
detail atop the roof. When he went
back to take a new photo, he found the
building had already been torn down.
Packer's project "is helpful," he
says. "It's nice to have (photographs
of) these old things."
The difficulties Packer has
encountered have only made him more
determined to finish the project. He
is putting together a slide show of
the synagogues he has photographed and
plans to take it to local synagogues
and other institutions as soon as it
is complete. There's talk of a show of
his photographs at the Skokie Library.
And he hopes to have a book out in
time for next year's High Holidays.
The working title is "Doors of
Redemption: The Forgotten Synagogues
of Chicago."
"When people look at my
pictures, they evoke emotion," he
says.
But Packer is not content with a
simple photographic records. He wants
to flesh out the photos with stories.
He has secured a research assistant at
the University of Chicago, a student
in history of religion and sociology
who is helping him with his research
for a class project. Her work will be
helpful, but Packer is also relying on
the local Jewish community for more
aid.
"The true stories of the synagogues
and temples are not in the buildings
or even in the book of photographs,"
he says. "The real stories are behind
the doors of these synagogues-the
memories of parents and grandparents,
the bar and bat mitzvahs, the
families, friends and neighbors. These
are the real stories."
Packer is reaching out to Chicago
Jewish News readers to complete those
stories. He is inviting all readers to
send him photographs, artifacts (for
instance, High Holiday tickets or
synagogue newsletters) and any other
memorabilia from Chicago temples and
synagogues.
"The book is a skeleton," he
says. "The readers who show their
support would clothe it."
On a strictly personal level, Packer
says the project has given his life an
additional dimension.
"I needed to figure out the whole
reason I was put on earth," he
says. "Now I know what my purpose was.
This was the reason-to be an active
participant in saving a part of
Chicago's cultural history."
Robert Packer invites all
Chicago Jewish News readers to send
him their photographs, stories and
memorabilia connected with any Chicago-
area synagogue. Contact him at (847)
808-8485 or by e-mail at
Rpacker820@aol.com.